Co-opetition of Civilizations | Competition of Civilizations and China’s Strategy for Europe ③: Different emphases of cooperation with other countries.
The first two articles demonstrate why France should become China’s primary strategic partner in the European Union (even Europe). This paper discusses how China cooperates with European countries, including major powers and major countries in the sub-region.
Strategically speaking, Europe belongs to the Christian civilization circle, in which Western Europe and Northern Europe belong to the Protestant-Catholic civilization circle, most of Central and Eastern Europe belong to the Protestant-Catholic civilization circle and the Orthodox civilization circle, and a few belong to the Islamic Sunni civilization circle. China implements general cooperation in Europe, but the cooperation focuses on several countries in Protestant-Catholic civilization circle, plus several countries in Orthodox civilization circle (Russia is not the object of this article). As far as the economic field is concerned, Europe is a cluster of developed economies. Most of these countries have the following conditions: infrastructure needs to be updated, the service industry is developed but the manufacturing industry is hollowed out, the information technology industry is dominated by the United States, the population is aging, and the labor force, especially skilled workers, is lacking. China has comparative advantages in capital, technology, infrastructure capacity, manufacturing industry, and so on. According to the specific conditions of different countries, it can formulate corresponding key cooperation areas and cooperation projects.
I. Cooperation between China and France
Alliance diplomacy mainly exists in the Protestant-Catholic civilization circle and some other countries in the civilization circle, and its number is less than one-third of the United Nations Member States. Non-aligned diplomacy is the choice of most countries in the world, including China. Independent peaceful diplomacy inherits China’s traditional strategic culture and diplomatic concept, and it is the diplomatic starting point to promote the rejuvenation of Chinese civilization. In the new era, it is manifested in building a global partner diplomatic network, and "building different types of partner diplomacy and determining key strategic partners" is its proper meaning. Within the EU, France is a suitable option. It is necessary to emphasize that China cannot and should not form an alliance with France. Nor does France have the will and conditions to form an alliance with China.
The first two articles have already discussed the necessity of strategic cooperation between China and France. The operation of Sino-French strategic cooperation needs to carry out comprehensive special research and formulate corresponding plans, which should be adhered to for a long time in the process of implementation and not affected by the short-term political climate in France (such as the conflict between Russia and Ukraine). The key points of Sino-French economic cooperation have been discussed above. On the whole, it should be an area where both sides can complement each other and are willing to cooperate. Under the current situation, personnel exchange is a major focus, including tourism, cultural and educational exchanges among young people, improvement of infrastructure and public services, and areas where both sides have superior technical cooperation and can complement each other.
The field of advanced technology is another focus. During the Cold War of 1970s and 1980s, unlike other western powers, France cooperated with China in manufacturing, telecommunications, nuclear power and other fields, and became a strategic key country for China to introduce foreign technology and equipment. Now, France, as a partner outside the core circle of American circle diplomacy, and a western power that is suppressed and humiliated by the United States from time to time, may be willing to cooperate with China in the field of its technological advantages due to the needs of national strategy and economic and social development in the process of constantly setting a new threshold for Sino-US cooperation in the field of technology. This largely depends on whether China can seize the opportunity to promote cooperation. Now China’s understanding of French is far more than that in 1970s and 1980s, and there is reason to do better than then.
There is also a lot of room in the functional fields such as climate change response, clean energy technology, water resources development and utilization, cultural relics protection and restoration technology, and cultural promotion.
Outside Europe, the strategic cooperation between China and France is mainly focused on French-speaking countries, especially in West Africa. At present, there have been several agreements on third-party market cooperation between China and France, but the implementation is not ideal. Perhaps we can try the strategy of "grasping key countries and key projects for pilot projects"
Sino-French strategic and economic cooperation does not affect China’s cooperation with other European countries, including Germany, Britain, Italy, Spain, Poland and Sweden. But it needs to focus on different fields and regions (including within Europe and outside Europe).
Second, the cooperation between China and Germany
Getting along between countries is influenced by many factors, such as national strategy, economic interests, cultural similarity, and mutual affection among the people. German people’s goodwill towards China is obviously weaker than that of France. Cultural similarity and national strategy determine that Germany must pursue better relations with the United States than France. The German population in the United States has reached 80 million, and these people usually support strengthening relations with Germany, which is the cultural basis for Germany to strengthen relations with the United States. Therefore, Sino-German relations are mainly reflected in the fields of economy, trade, culture, science and technology, education and so on.
Germany is a representative of Protestant countries in Western Europe and Northern Europe. Except Bavaria, most German Christians belong to Lutheran Sect. Germany is also the country with the largest population and the strongest economic strength in the European Union. With the strengthened economic strength and the national defense force rapidly promoted by the Russian-Ukrainian conflict, it will greatly enhance its influence in the political and security fields inside and outside the EU, and "becoming an unparalleled leader of the EU" is Germany’s national strategic goal. The close relationship with France can hardly prevent Germany from pursuing this goal. Strengthening relations with the United States is a starting point for achieving strategic goals.
Economically, as a representative of the Rhine model, Germany has achieved a relatively balanced regional economic development in the process of becoming a developed economy. The degree of tripartite cooperation between government, enterprises and workers is higher than that of France, Britain, Italy and other countries, and the labor-capital relationship is relatively stable and harmonious. While owning a large number of large enterprise groups with global competitiveness, small and medium-sized enterprises have been protected and developed, and a large number of invisible world champions have been formed in specific fields and products. Paying attention to the vocational training of manufacturing and skilled workers laid the foundation for the steady development of German economy and maintaining its global competitiveness. Coupled with the government’s support from policies and taxes, Germany has maintained a foreign trade surplus for a long time. From 2003 to 2008, Germany was the world’s largest exporter of goods, and it is still the largest trading country in Europe, second only to China and the United States in the world. Half of the jobs are related to exports, and one third of corporate profits come from foreign trade. In terms of trade export targets, Europe accounts for more than half, and has always accounted for a large surplus in trade with France.
Central and Eastern Europe is a region with great traditional influence in Germany, especially in the Balkans. After the Cold War, it is also a key area for German manufacturing transfer. In addition, Europe is earlier and more active than other regions in dealing with climate change, but there are differences in roles and functions. Britain is the first European country to promote the response to climate change, and has been concerned about this issue since Margaret Thatcher’s time. France is politically active, such as pushing the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. Germany, on the other hand, is a typical example of pragmatic promotion, and its nuclear power policy is very different from that of Britain and France. In the process of promoting nuclear power, it has vigorously promoted new energy and clean energy, and has formed technological advantages and rapid industrialization.
China’s cooperation with Germany focuses on economy, including automobiles and spare parts, machinery and equipment manufacturing, chemical industry, electronics and electricity. In the field of culture and education, vocational and technical education is a major focus. In the third-party market cooperation, Central and Eastern European countries are the first, followed by Germany’s influential countries, such as Angola in Africa, Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay in Latin America, and Papua New Guinea in Oceania. Climate change is also a major focus of Sino-German cooperation, and its potential and effect may be as good as or even better than Sino-US cooperation.
It is necessary to pay special attention to the third-party market cooperation between China and Germany in Central and Eastern Europe. At present, there are some disharmonious factors between the two sides in this regard. Regardless of Germany’s traditional influence in this region, Germany’s comprehensive influence in this region has risen sharply after the Cold War, and it has the ability to affect China’s cooperation with these countries. It is a manifestation to interfere with some projects by "not meeting EU standards". Cooperation with German is an important condition for China to promote China-Central and Eastern Europe cooperation in a sustainable way, which will help to reduce and remove some obstacles in China-Central and Eastern Europe cooperation.
Outside Europe, the focus of Sino-German third-party market cooperation is those countries with close relations with Germany in Africa and Latin America.
III. Cooperation between China and Britain
The Church of England, which is now regarded as Protestant, is strictly a moderate sect between Catholicism and Protestantism, and its distance from Catholicism is closer to Anglicanism. Different from continental Europe, the religious reform in England was carried out under the guidance of the king (queen) as a whole. It began with the formulation of the "Ten creed" in 1536, and after Henry VIII’s Book of the King in 1543, it was shaped into the "Thirty-nine creed" finalized by Elizabeth I in 1571. The Church of England does not force believers to accept these creed, but since 1865, Anglican pastors must confirm these principles.
The Anglican Church has absorbed some Protestant teachings and practices, such as weakening the hierarchy of the church, allowing priests (elders) to get married, and being recognized as Protestant by the Holy See, but it is still obviously different from the Calvinism believed by Puritans. Religious differences are the main reason for the conflict between the Anglican Church and the Puritans. The United States is a typical Protestant country, such as lutheranism (Lutheran), Calvinism (Reformed, Presbyterian), Puritanism (Baptist), etc. The overall influence is greater than that of the Episcopal Church (the United States does not use Anglicanism, but it is called episcopal Church), but the similarities in race and language make both Britain and the United States happy to maintain closer relations, which is the establishment of a "special relationship" between Britain and the United States.
Since 1971, the economic aggregate of Britain has been higher than that of France in most years. With the outstanding integration effect of the European Union (then called the European Community), Britain left the European Free Trade Association and joined the European Community, hoping to form a "troika" to lead Europe together with France and Germany after joining, but this has not been realized. Many aspects of foreign affairs and internal affairs are subject to the European Union, and the economy is also "not worth the loss", which is a major reason for Britain’s "Brexit".
After leaving the European Union, Britain is determined to become a "Global Britain". However, in the era of civilized competition, it is inevitable that more and more emphasis will be placed on the "special relationship between Britain and the United States", the Anglo-Saxon cultural ties and the importance of the Commonwealth. Its influence on the European continent can no longer be compared with that of France and Germany, and it has a relatively large influence only in some parts of Europe: mainly Denmark, Norway, Iceland in northern Europe and Poland in eastern Europe.
On Sino-British cooperation, Britain certainly emphasizes the special relationship with the United States, but Britain has its own national interests, national strategy and cultural self-confidence in old Europe, and has always maintained a certain degree of independence in its diplomacy with China. The national strategy determined by Britain after Brexit is to become a "global Britain", which has many similarities with the "community of human destiny", "Belt and Road" and partner diplomacy, such as the service industry (especially the financial sector) and Commonwealth countries. Britain firmly believes that London, as a global financial center, can play the role that new york Stock Exchange and Nasdaq Stock Exchange can’t or won’t play, such as accepting China enterprises to be listed on London Stock Exchange. Britain’s mature legal system can provide various services for China enterprises’ global development, and Britain’s position as a global financial and service center also needs China’s support.
Britain’s influence in Commonwealth countries includes language, culture, political system, economic and trade relations, legal system and many other fields. Third-party market cooperation between China and Britain can give full play to each other’s advantages to promote the high-level construction of the Belt and Road Initiative and implement global development initiatives, and play a unique role in building a global partnership network and implementing global security initiatives. In the fields of traditional security and advanced technology, Britain is obviously restrained by the United States, but there is still a lot of room in the fields of non-traditional security, animal husbandry, cultural and educational exchanges. Britain still wants to maintain its own independent space in diplomacy, which is more and more obvious in the era of civilized competition.
Iv. China’s cooperation with Italy and Spain
These two countries are the third and fourth largest economies in the European Union, and they are both Catholic countries. However, their economic aggregate and development level are obviously different from those of France, as are their military strength and political influence within the European Union. However, Italy and Spain are not as enthusiastic about European integration as Western and Central and Eastern European countries, and even hope to strengthen their relations with China to enhance their position in the EU and gain more practical benefits. The rise of the Italian five-star sports party and the signing of the "Belt and Road" cooperation document with China are its manifestations. How to deepen the cooperation between China and these two countries depends on the efforts of scholars who study these two countries in China. According to the author’s observation, in addition to tourism, clothing industry and leather industry, there is still a lot of potential to be tapped in the cooperation of culture and education and manufacturing industry (especially in the positioning and market expansion of small and medium-sized enterprises).
Globally, Spain’s influence is mainly in Spanish-speaking countries, especially in Latin America and Africa. Italy’s influence is mainly in North Africa. Therefore, China cooperates with third-party markets in Spain, mainly in some Spanish-speaking countries. There are a large number of Spanish-speaking countries, so it is difficult to establish a cooperation mechanism between China and all Spanish-speaking countries. First, we can focus on the cooperation mechanism with a single Spanish-speaking country. Next, we may try to establish a small multilateral cooperation mechanism with several Spanish-speaking countries on the basis of bilateral mechanisms. The third-party market cooperation between China and Italy is mainly in North Africa. Similarly, the cooperation between China and Portugal is mainly in Portuguese-speaking countries. The forum on economic and trade cooperation between China and Portuguese-speaking countries has been running for many years and achieved certain results, but there is still room for improvement, especially with Brazil, the largest Portuguese-speaking country.
V. Cooperation between China, Sweden and Finland
Among the Nordic countries, Sweden has the largest population, among which Lutherans account for about 80% of the population. Strategically, it pursues the policy of neutrality for a long time, and only applies to join NATO after the conflict between Russia and Ukraine; It is the largest economy in northern Europe. It only joined the European Union in 1995 but did not join the euro zone. The service industry is developed, with employees accounting for 70% of the total population; Science, technology and education are developed, and they are more open-minded in accepting immigrants from different cultural backgrounds; The manufacturing industry is developed and has formed global competitiveness in emerging industries. However, in recent years, Sweden has strengthened its cultural identity and western political values, and strengthened its relationship with NATO in security; Strengthening cooperation with countries in Protestant-Catholic civilization circle in relations with China tends to be tough. Therefore, the cooperation between China and Sweden should focus on medium and low sensitive areas, such as machinery, chemicals, mining, automobiles, biology, medicine, environmental protection, information and food processing.
Judging from the depth and breadth of cooperation with China, Finland ranks among the best in the Nordic countries. Due to historical and practical reasons, we pay attention to maintaining a certain balance between the East and the West in the orientation of national diplomacy. Finland has always pursued a friendly policy towards China, and was one of the first western countries to establish diplomatic relations with China. It has a developed economy, a high level of scientific research and education, and many advanced technologies. China also attaches importance to its relations with Finland. In the era of civilized competition, Finland should become China’s first strategic partner in Nordic diplomacy. How to further deepen Sino-Finnish relations requires China’s overall consideration, careful planning and sustained promotion.
VI. Cooperation between China and other countries
In addition to Poland, bilateral cooperation also includes Central and Eastern Europe. Poland is the representative of "new Europe" in the eyes of the United States. Catholicism has more influence in Poland than France and even more than Germany. However, Poland’s old and new doubts and fears about Germany made it completely fall to the United States in security after the Cold War, and it was even more pro-American than Germany.
The conflict between Russia and Ukraine has promoted Poland’s position in NATO and the European Union, and helped Poland to limit Germany’s influence, especially in Central and Eastern Europe. However, Poland still needs more strategic support to balance Germany’s increasing influence in Central and Eastern Europe, and then play its position and influence as the largest country in Central and Eastern Europe. Poland is a relatively successful transitional economy, and its economic development has entered a fast track. However, the United States can play a limited role in Poland’s economic development and infrastructure construction, and the market, capital and technology of the European Union cannot fully meet Poland’s needs.
In the cooperation with China, Poland hopes to become the gateway for China enterprises and products to enter the EU market, increase economic and trade cooperation with China, especially export to China, attract more China funds and technology, help its rapid economic development, and participate in the upgrading of its infrastructure. All these provide strategic, political, economic and cultural space for the cooperation between China and Poland.
In terms of the depth and breadth of cooperation, Serbia and Hungary are among the top countries in Central and Eastern Europe, and both countries belong to the framework of China-Central and Eastern Europe cooperation. Greece is an example of cooperation between China and southern European countries. These three countries have typically demonstrated the achievements of building the "Belt and Road" and building a network of partner diplomatic relations in Central and Eastern Europe and Southern Europe. With China’s further global development initiative and global security initiative, how to build a new cooperation framework and deepen cooperation with three typical countries is a topic that China officials, business circles and academic circles need to work together to deal with.
VII. Summary
The world is entering a long period of civilized competition. "All civilized circles strengthen their internal identification, construct circle diplomacy with foreign countries, and cooperate and compete among civilized bodies" has become the main feature of international relations. It is an inevitable choice for China to realize the revival of civilization by peaceful means. China is not afraid of competition but is committed to cooperation. The unfair competition pressure mainly comes from the increasingly insecure United States. Europe and the United States belong to the Protestant-Catholic civilization circle, and they are also one of the three largest economies in the world. Therefore, China’s diplomatic strategy towards Europe needs to be considered repeatedly and implemented calmly.
The United States listed China as a long-term strategic competitor and suppressed China for a long time. In this context, how to better strive for and make use of the European market is a major focus of China’s diplomacy towards Europe. Solving economic problems cannot rely solely on economic means. Europe’s China policy is mainly decided by itself, but China’s attitude and practice will also affect Europe’s policy choice. Therefore, China should have an overall diplomatic plan for Europe, and build a relatively stable political relationship with European countries to promote the stability of economic relations with Europe. For China at this stage, it is particularly important to classify the European partner countries, determine the primary partner countries and important partner countries, and make long-term policies to establish stable political and strategic relations with these countries, thus laying the necessary foundation for the stable development of economic relations.
Cultural characteristics, France’s strategic interests and China’s strategic needs determine that France, rather than other countries, should become China’s primary strategic partner in Europe. China should also maintain and deepen cooperation with other European powers such as Germany, Britain, Spain, Italy, Sweden, Poland, etc., but it is mainly limited to certain areas and certain subregions, including areas where these countries have comparative advantages and areas that they hope to strengthen. Sub-region refers to a part of Europe and third-party market countries.
China cooperates with the third-party markets of these countries-mainly in French-speaking countries, especially in West Africa, mainly in Central and Eastern Europe, mainly in Commonwealth countries, mainly in Spain and mainly in North Africa. China’s cooperation with Sweden and Poland is mainly at home, but in terms of the depth and breadth of cooperation, Finland is among the best in northern Europe, while Serbia, Hungary and Greece are among the best in Central and Eastern Europe and Southern Europe.
"European integration is still a long-term process. Although we want to support the efforts of European integration, we cannot regard the possible future of Europe as the current reality." "So far, the EU has not established an effective common diplomatic and security mechanism, let alone a global strategy for Europe." This is the judgment of Ding Yifan in 2019. The author thinks it is still applicable at present, which coincides with the author’s motivation to write these three articles.
"Co-opetition of civilizations" is a column by Xue Li, a researcher at the Institute of World Economics and Politics of China Academy of Social Sciences. In the era of "all civilizations tend to be involuted, and different civilizations compete and cooperate", this column will take this as the keynote to discuss different topics of "international strategy" and "China’s diplomacy".
(This article is from The Paper, please download the "The Paper" APP for more original information)
Reporting/feedback